The
expatriates who lived in Ubud during the 1930s were
a handful of patrician, serious minded people -
composers, painters and scholars - whose work helped
reveal to the world the beauty and complexity of
Balinese culture. The expatriate residents of today
are a swarm of hedonists and businessmen restaurateurs,
jewelers and film-makers rather more into marketing
the culture than in understanding it. Nonetheless,
standards of cultural chic set over 50 years ago
are still being maintained.
Expatriate
chic in Ubud began with people like Jane Belo -
the American anthropologist and observer of ritual
trance - and Walter Spies, the German painter, musician
and dilettante par excellence. Spies' charm was
legendary, and anyone of any importance who came
to Bali in the 1930s came to visit him. His lifestyle
was irresistibly chic.
Cokorda
Agung Sukawati, Ubud's ruling prince, granted Spies
permission to build' a house in Campuan. His double-story
villa with outbuildings and swimming pool later
became the Tjampuhan Hotel, and must have been wonderful
fifty years ago. Spies had many Balinese dancer
and musician friends and could command astonishing
performances to entertain his guests. He and painter
Rudolf Bonnet worked closely with local artists
and helped them sell their paintings to visitor
Above all, Spies had an impressive knowledge of
the culture and geography of Bali, as well as the
affection of the local people he thus made the perfect
tour guide.
Spies'
example attracted other Europeans to Bali to paint,
to compose and to study. Ubud soon became an outpost
of artistic and intellectual activity - as well
as a glamorous stop on the luxury liner circuit.
Cokorda Agung Sukawati was a cosmopolitan man who
enjoyed foreign guests and made them welcome in
the palace, setting an irreversible precedent for
tourism in Ubud.
By
the time of the Cokorda's death in 1978, Bali had
opened its curly gates to the budget travelers of
the world. Young Australians by the thousands helped
to make Kuta what it is - whatever it is - today;
and a new generation of Kuta expatriates fluttered
down to settle around Ubud. They built themselves
little bamboo huts out in the rice field (or next
to the cemetery or wherever else the. Balinese wouldn't
dream of living) and furnished them with batik curtains,
little cushions and wobbly bamboo furniture.
These
expats of the 1970s were back-to-earth mystics who
wanted nothing more than to become Balinese. They
strove to dance like the Balinese, play the gamelan
like the Balinese, speak Balinese like the Balinese,
even get sick like the Balinese (fashionable illnesses
were supposed to be caused by black magic). They
didn't really try to paint like the Balinese, but
they understood, like Spies, that the painting was
charming, and marketable.
Who
were these new expatriates? Some were artists and
scholars. Others were would-be artists and drop-out
scholars. The physically and mentally ill also found
a haven here: poet-inebriates; convalescents of
disease and divorce; the freshly-bereaved or newly-fired
- all sorts of people at odds with their fate came
to Ubud for a tropical-pastoral lullaby, and many
found new vocations.
Some
became amateur anthropologists in the emerging field
of "Baliology." (Say you are an amateur
anthropologist and you get a grant to write a thesis
on "Patterns of Courtship in Central Bali"
- all you have to do is have lots of dates with
Balinese of the sex of your preference and keep
a diary. If you can't get dates, you can make a
list of a lot of impertinent questions and pay a
student to go around the neighborhood collecting
the answers. This leaves you plenty of time to set
up house, meet friends for lunch at the Cafe Lotus,
and research courtship patterns in Candi Dasa.)
Aspiring
designer-entrepreneurs also find Bali a creative
paradise. It's so easy to realize an idea here.
(Say you're suddenly inspired to create a gigantic
lily made entirely of wood. All you have to do is
roll over and order someone to summon a woodcarver,
then tell him, as best you can, that if he can make
you a gigantic lily by tomorrow you'll give him
a whole dollar. After that it's only a matter of
charming the teeth off some millionaire's wife and
getting her to order seven hundred of them for her
ballroom. 'Men you close the deal by whispering
to her confidentially, "Let's make that prepaid,
shall we? You know they're all saving up for their
cremations, and it all goes to the gods anyway.")
Meanwhile
the Balinese of Ubud themselves were busy imitating
Walter Spies putting on dance performances and selling
paintings to tourists, guiding them around on tours
of Bali's beauty spots, dressing them up for the
temple and explaining the culture, and basically
luring the world to Ubud.
The
new expatriates resented this invasion of their
world, but (like the Balinese) saw the economic
potential in it. By the 1980s the boom was on. Expats
upgraded their houses from lumbung (rice granaries)
to wantilan (public halls); and furnishings were
the big bamboo sofas and elephantine cushions by
Linda Garland. Meanwhile, the Balinese were busily
upgrading their houses to look like western tract
houses.
Cultural
exchanges between East and West continue in Ubud.
In the 1930s, composers and choreographers devised
systems of notation for gamelan and dance. They
commissioned new gamelan sets, collaborated in new
dance forms and made documentary films of ritual
dances that have now flown away with the leyaks.
Expatriate scholars excavated ancient burial grounds
and speculated about prehistory. They solicited
funds for the restoration of monuments, transcribed
classical texts, accumulated archives and founded
libraries and museums.
Modern
expatriates also make documentaries, study music
and dance, and augment their archives. They also
teach their Balinese friends (or partners) to make
pasta and sorbet and martinis; and help them to
develop new skills like silk-screening and shipping.
Whether
Ubud is still a center of artistic and intellectual
activity is less the issue than whether it can once
again become a glamorous stop on the R&R circuit.
It would be wrong to deplore the new materialism;
Bali turns out to be part of the real world after
all. One can only hope that the cultural entrepreneurs
will become as epicurean as the cultural sponsors
of the '30s were learned.
The
recently opened Amandari Hotel just outside of Ubud
sets new standards worth studying - its sublime
architecture is an indictment of the execrable architecture
o other hotels nearly as expensive, and its management
philosophy defines high new standards of service.
Development
in Ubud is the right of its citizens; but Ubud is
no longer the same product it was ten years ago.
Funky accommodations and indecisive food are no
longer so forgivable, and simply raising the price
will not achieve glamor - it may take some artistic
and intellectual activity to do that.